Cultural intelligence research at Forticia: How institutions
reason, and answer
for it.
The institute’s practice of how it reasons, decides, justifies and stays accountable: the philosophy, governance and ethics behind every result, kept on the record where a stranger can check it.
Working commitments,
not a theory.
Each commitment names the failure it exists to prevent, because a failure is easier to recognise than a virtue. Open one to see what it means in practice and which ideas it borrows.
The failure it prevents
A result nobody tried to break.
In practice
- Ask where the flaw is before asking how to use the result.
- Remove the supposed cause and check that the effect goes quiet.
- Read fragility to small changes as a warning, and agreement across neighbouring settings as evidence.
The failure it prevents
A regularity mistaken for knowledge.
In practice
- Say who is on the other side and why they cannot do otherwise.
- Match the speed of the proposed cause to the speed of the effect.
- Decline questions the world can never supply enough events to answer.
Where the idea comes from
The failure it prevents
Choosing the test after seeing the answer.
In practice
- Declare one specification in advance rather than sweeping until something fits.
- Examine sealed evidence once. A failed sealed test is final.
- Never tune a failed idea until it twitches.
The failure it prevents
Being fooled the same way twice.
In practice
- Write the autopsy, then move on.
- Screen every new idea against what has already failed.
- Retry a buried idea only after the standard itself improves, and then retry every case alike.
The failure it prevents
A decision nobody answers for.
In practice
- Name an owner for every output and every risk.
- Separate those who propose, build, review and decide.
- Keep the trail complete enough that nobody has to be asked.
Where the idea comes from
From a question
to the record.
Every idea takes the same road: declared, tested, sealed, reviewed, decided and recorded. A failure travels it too. Choose an outcome and watch the record fill in.
The idea survives every attempt to break it. The decision is kept with everything needed to replay it.
Decision record
A worked example of the shape of a decision, filed as the passage runs.- Question
- Written down before any evidence is examined.
- Mechanism
- Not yet filed
- Exploration
- Not yet filed
- Sealed test
- Not yet filed
- Review
- Not yet filed
- Decision
- Not yet filed
- Owner
- Not yet filed
- Trail
- Not yet filed
Objections stay
on the map.
A claim is only as good as the objections it has met. This map lays out one argument: premises, evidence, objections, replies, and the dissent that survives. Select a node, collapse a branch, or hide the dissent and see what the record loses.
Claim/Objection
Independent review slows decisions that are time-sensitive.
A specific reason a premise or the claim may fail. It deserves an answer, not a rebuttal of tone.
Rules, standards,
and the ideas behind them.
Each clause can be written as a rule or as a standard, and each traces to the work that explains why the safeguard exists. Choose a clause to light its lines.
Clause §1
Declare the question first
The question and the test are written down before the evidence is examined.
The failure it preventsSearching until something fits.
Cheap to apply and predictable. It can be gamed at the edges and miss cases nobody foresaw.
Rules cost more to write; standards cost more to apply (Kaplow, 1992). Most working charters use both.
Choosing when the
odds are unknown.
Frank Knight separated risk, where probabilities can be measured, from uncertainty, where they cannot. Robust decision making stress-tests a choice against many futures instead of betting on one forecast. Move the slider and see which rules notice.
Weights each future by its probability. It needs the odds, and trusts them.
Expected value chooses commit fully.
With the odds trusted, expected value chooses commit fully. With no idea of the odds, it chooses stage it. Maximin, minimax regret and robust satisficing choose wait or stage it and do not need the odds at all.
| Option | Expected value | Worst future | Largest regret | Futures above threshold |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| A · Commit fully | 76.5 | 15 | 45 | 2 of 5 |
| B · Stage it | 66.5 | 40 | 25 | 4 of 5 |
| C · Wait | 46.4 | 45 | 50 | 3 of 5 |
Arbitrary units, chosen to show the mechanics. The column of the active rule is marked.
- We will not fabricate evidence.Where evidence is missing we say null, and say what would fill the gap.
- We will not tune a failed idea until it twitches.A buried idea may return only when the test itself improves, and then every affected case is retried alike.
- We will not grade our own work.Someone else re-derives it from raw inputs and files a written critique, whoever the author is.
- We will not claim readiness we have not shown.Done means a stranger can replay it. Until then the honest states are parked, blocked or degraded.
- We will not keep what we learn from failure private within the team.The autopsy is filed where everyone can screen new ideas against it.
- Where does machine judgement end and hard rule begin?Models can propose and interpret. Rules should guard whatever cannot be undone. Where exactly the seam sits is still being worked out.
- Who chooses the frame, and who watches them?Pre-declared gates remove discretion. Class-aware frames put some back. Someone decides which class a case belongs to.
- Is it a better test, or a rationalised rescue?A verdict may be reopened when the standard improves. The line between improvement and rescue is a judgement.
- What keeps a standard legitimate when one hand writes it and systems apply it?Process, separation of roles and a record help. They do not settle it.
Latest papers
Cultural Intelligence
- Never Tune a CorpseWhen may a rejected idea be reopened? Simulated burial and exhumation rules, their false discovery cost, and how the graveyard can audit the court.16 min read
- When Approval Stops Carrying InformationA conditional-information measure of rubber-stamping, the defect rate where review rationally collapses, and which levers restore it. A simulation study.18 min read
Enquire about
this branch.
Workspaces are invite-only and role-gated, and an AI collaborator drafts by default: a lead approves before anything is written, with a full audit trail. Tell us what you would like to examine.
Further reading
- Karl Popper, Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
- Montesquieu, Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
- Federalist No. 51, Madison, 1788
- Merton, The Normative Structure of Science, 1942
- Estimating the reproducibility of psychological science, Open Science Collaboration, 2015
- Ostrom’s eight commons governance design principles
- Rules versus standards: an economic analysis, Kaplow, Duke Law Journal, 1992
- Robust Decision Making (RDM), Lempert and colleagues
- Explained: Knightian uncertainty, MIT News
- NIST AI Risk Management Framework 1.0
- Precommitment, Elster, Ulysses and the Sirens, 1979
- Imre Lakatos, Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
- Cargo Cult Science, Feynman, Caltech 1974
- The five principles of high-reliability organisations
- Goodhart’s law
- Toulmin model of argument